Research

Subvocalization: should you stop reading in your head?

Your inner voice helps you understand what you read, and blocking it hurts comprehension. What research says about subvocalization and how to read faster with it.

Lines of text with one word highlighted and a sound wave underneath

No. The voice you hear in your head while reading helps you understand the text. In studies where people had to drown it out, they understood less of what they read. The popular advice to "eliminate subvocalization and triple your reading speed" has no support in the research. You can, however, read faster with your inner voice, because it doesn't have to talk at the speed of speech.

What is subvocalization?

Subvocalization is the inner "saying" of the words you read. Your lips don't move. Some people hear a clear narrator; others only have a faint sense of how each word sounds. Reading researchers call it inner speech and treat it as a normal part of silent reading.

Speed-reading courses see it differently. We speak at around 183 words per minute, the argument goes, and the inner voice "reads" every word, so it must be the brake. Switch it off and your eyes can go as fast as they like. It sounds logical, but it rests on two assumptions that don't hold up.

Does subvocalization slow down reading?

The first assumption is that your inner voice keeps you at the speed of speech. The numbers say otherwise. Marc Brysbaert's meta-analysis of 190 studies found that adults read aloud at about 183 words per minute and read non-fiction silently at about 238 (Brysbaert, 2019, Journal of Memory and Language). If the voice in your head had to pronounce every word at speaking pace, silent reading couldn't be faster than reading aloud. Inner speech doesn't need to get every syllable right, and your mouth doesn't have to keep up. We go through these numbers in What is the average reading speed for adults?

That doesn't mean the voice never sets the pace. If you deliberately "enunciate" each word in your head, the way you would reading a bedtime story to a child, you will slow down. But slow reading more often has other causes: a hard text, an unfamiliar subject, unknown words, a wandering mind, and going back over a sentence that slipped past.

What happens when you block inner speech

The second assumption is that comprehension stays the same without the inner voice. The most data on this comes from a 2016 review of speed-reading research by Keith Rayner and four co-authors, all researchers of reading and eye movements (Rayner et al., 2016, Psychological Science in the Public Interest).

The review describes experiments in which people read while repeating unrelated words out loud. Repeating words ties up the speech system and blocks inner speech. These readers understood the passage less well. In a control condition they tapped a sequence with their fingers instead of speaking, and comprehension didn't drop. So comprehension dropped because speech was busy. Doing two things at once didn't hurt it.

The authors also note that attempts to eliminate inner speech lead to poorer comprehension when the text is reasonably difficult and requires making inferences. With an easy text, the loss may be small. A contract, a textbook or a research paper is exactly the harder kind of text.

One possible explanation is that the sound of words helps you hold the start of a sentence in memory until you reach the end, and catch meaning that depends on stress or intonation. Reading a hard sentence without that support is like doing mental arithmetic while someone next to you reads out other numbers.

How to read faster without fighting your inner voice

A better goal than silencing the voice is letting it go faster for as long as your understanding keeps up.

Match your pace to the text. You can read a light article or a novel faster and a dense chapter more slowly. Rayner and colleagues show that speeding up always costs something; the question is how much comprehension you can afford to give up on a given text. More on that in Speed reading: what works and what's a myth.

Check comprehension, not just speed. A words-per-minute score means nothing if you can't say what the text was about afterwards. After every faster attempt, ask yourself one question about the content.

Read a lot. According to Rayner's review, the people who read fast with good comprehension are the ones who read a lot and know many words. You recognise familiar words faster, so your inner voice doesn't have to stop on them. Why no trick replaces that is the subject of Does speed reading work?

Subvocalization and RSVP readers

An RSVP reader shows text one word, or one short group of words, at a time in a fixed spot on the screen, so your eyes don't have to jump along the lines. Some guides promote it as a way to "switch off" subvocalization: the words come so fast that the voice can't keep up. The studies above suggest that would cost you comprehension.

In the Readspresso RSVP reader you can change the pace smoothly and find the speed at which your inner voice still keeps up, and the speed at which you start losing the meaning. The Rayner review also points out a weakness of RSVP. Your eyes can't go back to an earlier word, and those regressions help comprehension. That's why the reader has a "⟲ sentence" button that jumps back to the start of the sentence. The reader with all three modes (RSVP, Pacer and Column Scan) is free.

Try this today

  1. Pick an easy text, such as a news article, and paste it into the reader in RSVP mode.
  2. Read the first paragraph at a pace that feels comfortable. Sum up in one sentence what it said.
  3. Raise the pace by 20–30 words per minute and read the next paragraph. Again, one sentence about the content.
  4. Keep going for as long as the answer comes without guessing. When you start guessing, step back one notch. That pace is your ceiling for this kind of text.

Don't try to silence the voice in your head along the way. Just notice what it does at the higher pace. You may find it pronounces the simplest words less carefully while still carrying the meaning of the sentence.